Favorites Videos
Articles
Pricing  
Sign in Register for free!
Sign in Register
CLOSE


How to evaluate Instagram accounts?

Feb 16, 2024, Update: Feb 16, 2024, author: Hairstrokes.com / Holistic PMU
Share this article
4

"Instagram is more intricate than it appears. Many brow artists excel in their services but overlook the detailed analysis of their accounts needed for true success. If you're only looking at basic numbers or aiming for a quick gain of your first 3000 followers with simple posts and engagement, it's time to think again. A deeper, more effective strategy is critical to growth, and grasping this concept is essential."

1. Background


This article was created in collaboration with Powderbrows.io, the digital marketing division of Powderbrows.com Research Center. The insights and conclusions drawn here are based on information from over 720 Instagram accounts the company has analyzed and worked with. The digital marketing team's experience is rooted in analyzing hundreds of campaigns from 2014-2023, with ongoing data collection. A majority of the Instagram accounts examined, over 77%, are within the EU, followed by 14% in the UK and the remainder mainly in the US. The fundamental mechanics and findings apply universally, regardless of location.

Instagram Account as Real Estate Property

Comparing an Instagram account to real estate helps you understand the value of your social media presence. Just as you would evaluate a property's type, location, and layout, similar considerations apply to your social media assets, especially as a Powder Brows, Hairstrokes, or Microblading artist. Next, we will examine the crucial aspects to consider when analyzing an Instagram account, akin to how a real estate appraiser assesses a property's value.

2. First Level: Foundational Metrics


The initial analysis examines basic metrics such as the account's handle, age, type (business, creator, or private), follower count, and other foundational metrics. This stage is similar to assessing a property's essential characteristics like type, size, and age. However, just as a real estate appraiser wouldn't solely rely on these aspects to determine a property's value, the same caution applies to evaluating an Instagram account.

For instance, a property on Manhattan's 5th Avenue could have a vastly different value from a similar property in a rural Eastern European area or a conflict zone. Similarly, if a property has legal or regulatory issues, owning it might become a liability due to potential legal troubles or required renovations. In the same way, the mere statistics of an Instagram account don't reveal its actual value.

What does this mean in the brow business?

Essentially, the basic stats on an Instagram account aren't very revealing. They provide initial information, but you won't know the actual demographics of followers, the percentage of fake followers, or the potential for engagement. Thus, these first-level metrics mainly offer a glimpse of what might happen or what the account owner wishes to present to the public.

An anonymous example

A woman is pointing at an enlarged Instagram account screenshot.

In this example, the initial statistics look promising, with about 24k followers, a reasonable engagement rate, and average likes. However, as discussed, this does not yet tell the whole story.

3. Second Level: Audience Authenticity


Evaluating the audience's authenticity provides insights into the potential value of an account. A high percentage of fake followers significantly reduces an account's value. Suppose most followers are from regions unlikely to use your services, such as Brazil, India, or other Asian areas, while you operate in NYC. In that case, they're unlikely to ever avail of your brow services. This is especially true if the followers are primarily males aged 18-24 or possibly bots.

In real estate terms, a property in a war zone or disaster-prone area has little value, regardless of its interior or condition.

What it means in the brow business

You can determine if an artist has an organic following. Professional tools provide immediate factual information about this. If the percentage of fake followers is high, the account owner may have bought them, or someone (often a competitor) has done it to disrupt organic reach, a common and known practice.

Cleansing the Account - Battling the Illness

There's no universal method for "cleaning" accounts of fake followers. The process is akin to a patient fighting a severe illness - while it might be possible to overcome the issue, the remedy could be drastic. Instagram and Meta frown upon mass actions on accounts, which can lead to suspension after just one warning. Manually removing fake followers is feasible only up to a certain number, as managing many fake followers becomes increasingly complex in time and effort.

A Standard for Fake Followers in Brow Artists' Accounts

Context is critical when assessing fake follower ratios. Larger accounts with over 1 million followers might reasonably have around 20% fake followers. Ideally, accounts with 50,000 to 100,000 followers should have less than 15% fake followers, while smaller accounts with 10,000 to 50,000 followers should aim for fewer than 10%. However, a fake follower ratio over 25% generally indicates a problem in the account's growth strategy.

4. Third Level: Audience Demographics


At this stage, a deep dive into the demographics of your followers is essential. You'll want to look at their geographic location, demographic data, gender, age groups, and psychographics like interests and followed accounts. This detailed analysis offers insights crucial to understanding the actual value of your account. For Powder Brows, Hairstrokes, and microblading artists, ideally, the male audience should not exceed 5%. If an artist's account has over 50% male followers (assuming they're not fake), it might be better suited for different services, as they're less likely to seek brow services.

What it means in the brow business

For a brow artist's account, a typical follower distribution might include 15% aged 18-24, 50% between 25-34, and 20% aged 35-44. The rest are usually older, with about 1.3% being male. Geographically, most of your audience should be within 100 miles of your location.

Like evaluating a property's potential based on its favorable location, this phase of analysis is about assessing the potential value of your Instagram account. However, a favorable audience demographic doesn't automatically mean the account is a hidden gem; sometimes, what seems promising on paper might not translate into real value.

Anonymous example

A woman is pointing at the stats of fake followers of an Instagram account.

Using analysis tools, we can determine the credibility of an account. For instance, an account with 57.44% follower credibility means that 42.56% of its followers are fake. This doesn't automatically mean the account owner bought these followers; sometimes, competitors purchase counterfeit followers to sabotage an account's organic reach. Artists might not even realize this and mistakenly attribute unexpected follower growth to other reasons.

The fact that most followers are from Latin America (20.44%) further questions the account's credibility. Our analytical tools often reveal an unusually high percentage of male followers, which is atypical for artists' accounts, where the norm is around 5%. This anomaly also points towards the inauthenticity of the follower base.

5. Fourth Level: More specific properties


Target Demographics, Psychographics, and Behavior

Appearances can be misleading. Sometimes, an artist's follower count seems unusually high compared to peers, leading to suspicions about rapid follower accumulation. A significant concern is when followers who match the intended demographics follow for misguided reasons, becoming a "dangerous burden.”

"All-eaters"

All-eaters

In social media marketing, there's a term for those who indiscriminately like and follow everything they encounter. Often referred to in a more critical tone (some well-known marketers have gone on record calling them “unemployed - and a medical term”), we'll term them "all-eaters" here. These individuals, while active, contribute little value, behaving like a network summoned en masse to inflate engagement and manipulate algorithms. Their presence is like a stealthy disease, diminishing the account's marketing potential. Their engagement usually dwindles over time, with very few converting into paying customers.

A woman pointing at an enlarged Instagram account statistics.

Relevance to the Brow Business

How does this apply to artists? Some agencies offer "organic growth" services, promising to stay under the radar of tools detecting fake followings. They might use incentives or creative tactics to draw followers, sometimes even employing ads in online games, creating a legion of followers with little genuine interest in Powder Brows, Hairstrokes, or microblading.

Analyzing Behavior Patterns

A closer look at behavior patterns offers deeper insights. Examining organic engagement rates, the balance between comments and likes, and follower behavior changes over time reveals psychographics and attitudes. Comparing these shifts in engagement to other brow artists on Instagram enhances the analysis.

An account with genuinely engaged users, even less active, is more valuable than one filled with fake followers. However, the account's real value must correspond with these additional statistics, providing a more comprehensive view of its worth. This fourth level of analysis, while insightful, is confined to Instagram. It resembles a house that looks good outside but might have hidden issues beneath, much like termites in an otherwise fine-looking house.

6. Fifth Level: A Holistic Perspective


At this advanced stage, the digital marketing team at Powderbrows.io employs a holistic approach. Using over 20 tools, we aim to understand an artist's true popularity and behavior within Instagram and across the digital landscape. We examine shifts in popularity, investigate the triggers behind significant changes, and use historical data dating back to 2016 to chart the account's growth and identify trends. This perspective helps determine if an account's growth is artificially boosted or genuinely organic.

A woman is pointing at Instagram account statistics.

Importance in the Brow Business

We achieve a more comprehensive view by integrating this information with insights from search engines and websites referencing the artist. This enables us to understand what drives popularity in specific areas and connect these trends to significant events or achievements in the artist's life. This level of analysis not only refines our assessment but also reveals the underlying factors influencing the account's dynamics.

Real Estate Analogy

Comparable to real estate appraisal, this analysis is like having a complete historical record of a property. We uncover hidden details about its actual state, allowing us to evaluate its value more precisely. Just as a thorough property inspection might reveal issues not apparent at first glance, this comprehensive approach to analyzing Instagram accounts exposes the more profound, often unseen factors that contribute to an account's actual worth and potential.

7. Challenges in Brow Training


Overlooking a Basic Approach

Comprehensive analysis of Instagram accounts is vital, particularly for aspiring artists in Powder Brows or microblading, as it offers a realistic view of their potential in the brow business. Most brow trainers, often without ill intent, haven't conducted such in-depth analysis. For many, a thorough evaluation of accounts is out of reach. The tools required are either custom-built or very expensive, making it impractical for individual trainers to invest in them.

The Typical Scenario - Skilled Students, Limited Clientele

In the Powder Brows, Hairstrokes, and Microblading industry, most trainers are not just educators but skilled practitioners. They excel in the procedures and understand the craft's technical nuances. They're also proficient in imparting these skills effectively. For motivated students, learning the technical aspects of brow crafting is achievable. Our experience with research, where over 3000 students have participated over the years, shows that while people have different learning paces, acquiring technical skills is not the main barrier to starting a career as a brow artist.

8. From Zero to One


Developing Technical Skills: A Continuous Horizontal Journey

For novice artists, the challenge often isn't about acquiring technical skills, as these can be progressively improved. Skills like mastering Whip or Pendulum moves or refining microblading patterns can be honed over time. Factually, improvement comes from practicing correctly. Unless fundamental errors are made during practice, it's rare for technical skills not to advance with consistent effort. The path to technical mastery might not be strictly linear, but the likelihood of improvement is high. Progress might occur in small daily increments or through sporadic leaps, but overall, it shows a positive upward trend. Technical skills, therefore, typically follow a horizontal trajectory, marked by minor fluctuations but generally upward movement.

True Marketing Challenge - Requiring Vertical Advancement

In his book "From Zero to One," Peter Thiel discusses the importance of vertical progress in new ventures. Vertical progress (moving from 0 to 1) involves creating novel concepts or innovations that disrupt existing markets, as opposed to horizontal progress (moving from 1 to n), which extends existing ideas. Thiel suggests that vertical progress is crucial for significant business breakthroughs. If a starting artist’s social media presence and assets are almost non-existent in the brow business, achieving a successful start might require substantial, innovative steps. For artists at the beginning of their journey, the challenge often isn't just improving their craft but making a significant mark in the market, which often requires creative, distinct strategies and a bit of ingenuity.

Thus, Thiel posits that vertical progress - creating new concepts and distinct value - is vital for businesses to flourish. In the realm of beauty, specifically the brow business, this translates to the following: If a starting artist's social media presence and assets are initially at ground zero or close to it, achieving a successful start can require something akin to a miracle.

Tips from Trainers: Not Always Applicable

When starting from the ground up, the leap from zero to one is a unique challenge, incomparable to strategies for growing an Instagram account at any other stage. This is akin to moving from no income to establishing a sustainable livelihood. It's relatively more straightforward for a trainer who accumulated most of their followers years ago to offer advice on adding another 1000 or 3000 followers. They can provide valid recommendations based on their experiences, highlighting the importance of consistent posting, engaging with followers, creating captivating content, and delivering value through reels. However, while effective for an account growing from 75k to 78k followers, these strategies may not be practical for an account aiming for a significant initial increase. These strategies might pose an overwhelming challenge for an account trying to gain its first 3000 followers.

Well-meaning Naivety, Lacking Ill Intent

Similarly, well-meaning yet simplistic encouragements like, "Just learn Powder Brows or microblading, and your 10k followers will turn into clients!" are often unproductive. Most trainers aren't intentionally misleading their students; they don't understand deeply. They don't analyze accounts on all five levels, and their resources don't allow for such extensive research. As a result, their advice can lead many students to have unrealistic expectations far beyond what's achievable in reality. These trainers mean well, but without a comprehensive understanding, their guidance might inadvertently set students up for disappointment.

9. Conclusions


Understanding the Path Ahead

In the digital realm, particularly with Instagram accounts, a comprehensive understanding necessitates a five-level analysis.

  • Initial public information and engagement metrics,
  • Audience credibility scrutiny,
  • Geographic and demographic distribution examination among followers,
  • In-depth psychographic assessment and behavior analysis,
  • Holistic investigation beyond Instagram. Only through this multifaceted approach can the actual value of an account be accurately determined.

A Caution Against Unsubstantiated Positivity

Trainers and educators must avoid giving overly generalized advice for account growth. Such universal strategies are akin to prescribing a single type of vitamin to all patients; while beneficial for some, it lacks the individualized approach necessary for diverse situations. Each account has unique needs, and growth strategies should be tailored accordingly.

The Vertical Leap: From Zero to One

Aspiring students in the Powder Brows or microblading industry must understand that progressing from zero to one is a significant challenge. Organic growth can be more complex than anticipated, especially from the outset. If starting from scratch or with an account not aligned with target demographics, the focus should shift from mastering technical skills to effectively growing the account's reach and acquiring the first substantial batch of followers. This vertical leap is crucial and often requires strategic, innovative thinking, and that is what our digital branch, powderbrows.io, provides for artists.
 
  Readers suggest
Personal branding and pocket brow brands 
 
Brow artist’s budget for getting started 
 
Offline and online marketing in brow business 
 
 
 Read a longer version
Find this interesting?
or
 
Comments
 
Sanda
Monday, Mar 18, 2024

Another excellent piece that has been really useful. I know many of the criteria but not all :)

Jenny
Tuesday, Feb 20, 2024

Great article and beautiful examples – totally eye-opening stuff. Love the article and love the site.

Betty
Tuesday, Feb 20, 2024

I have found so much interesting material on this site. I am a hairstrokes artist and this site has helped me a lot. Another eye-opening article.

Erica
Saturday, Feb 17, 2024

Very informative and eye opening. I think that a very large number of PMU artist actually have lots of fake followers – wether they bought those, someone else bought or they just have gotten those.


Want to learn Hairstrokes?
Your name*
E-mail*


Hairstrokes.com is a Powderbrows.com LLC company. It serves as the premier resource for material related to Hairstrokes - the most natural technique for creating brow pigmentation. For collaboration opportunities, contact us here.
Powderbrows.com partner in Scandinavia: Brows.fi
Holistic PMU
Powderbrows.com
Hairstrokes.com
Lipblush.com
Combobrows.com
Everyoung.com




Company
About us
Contact us!
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
User
Account
Log In
Register
Upgrade!
© 2024. Powderbrows.com LLC. 225 Park Avenue, NY, NY, 10003, USA. All rights reserved. Terms of Service and Privacy Policy   |    Sitemap